The contractor ripped everything out including the studs and we sold all the salvageable stuff. The old bathroom vanity, mirror, and beige toilet, the old gas fireplace insert, a couple of doors, and even the drop ceiling were posted to Craigslist and scooped up by several people.
There were a few other things that we couldn't sell, so we donated those items to the Habitat Restore.
For our new reconfigured bathroom, we were able to score these on Craigslist: a brand new white Toto toilet ($50), enough gray porcelain floor tile for this bath and a later project ($11), and the new IKEA vanity ($230).
What I learned from this project:
1. Gray and yellow is my new favorite color combo.
2. Contractors are very skeptical of homeowners making purchases on their own.
3. I respect their views...to a point.